diff --git a/zip-XXXX.rst b/zip-XXXX.rst index 1a70f0aa..a25885d5 100644 --- a/zip-XXXX.rst +++ b/zip-XXXX.rst @@ -135,32 +135,28 @@ privacy proponents who have driven this ecosystem forward and represent its values. Nevertheless, their mode of operation today skews a healthy balance of power in Zcash governance. -The mechanisms of that skew are the Zcash trademark, held by the ECC, and -primary client software development, now split between the ECC and the -Foundation. +The mechanisms of that skew are the Zcash trademark, held jointly by the +Foundation and the ECC, and primary client software development, now split +between the ECC and the Foundation. -In a disagreement between miners, users, and developers, the ECC has the -unilateral option of enforcing the Zcash trademark, effectively allowing them -to choose a winning fork against the will of users, miners, and other -developers. +In a disagreement between miners, users, and developers, the Foundation and ECC +have the option of enforcing the Zcash trademark, effectively allowing them to +choose a winning fork against the will of users, miners, and other developers. -While the Foundation's maintenance of the `zebrad` client would normally allow -them to "soft veto" a network upgrade, they don't have a similar veto on the -Zcash trademark enforcement. +In addition, the Foundation's sole maintenance of the `zebrad` client allows +them to "soft veto" a network upgrade. -Compounding these issues, the Foundation and the ECC aren't arms-length entities -as they're organized today. +Unfortunately, the Foundation and the ECC aren't organized as arms-length +entities today. This situation poses a number of problems for new and existing Zcash users, as well as both entities. -* The threat of a central entity overriding (or being forced to override) the - will of users undermines self-sovereignty. +* The threat of two entangled entities overriding (or being forced to override) + the will of users undermines self-sovereignty. * The ECC and Foundation are both put at legal risk. As entangled entities, they're remarkably similar to a single entity when trying to minimize regulatory risk. -* Power between the two entites *hasn't* been decentralized. The ECC remains - a unilateral power, as well as a single point of failure. The "crowding out" problem -------------------------- @@ -324,7 +320,7 @@ The principal developer shall make a number of guarantees. the Foundation as assurance. 2. They shall maintain a well-run board and employ a qualified CFO. 3. In addition to the existing open-source requirements, they shall agree to - assign any trademarks or patents relevant to Zcash to the Foundation. + assign any patents relevant to Zcash to the Foundation. In exchange, the principal developer is granted an indefinite minimum dev fee allocation of 20%, with a maximum allocation of 35% of the total fee, as