Previously we set the crate versions to 3.x, so that the major version was
aligned with the NU version. But we want to be able to make API changes
independently of the NU schedule.
Zcashd will blindly request more block headers as long as it got 160
block headers in response to a previous query, EVEN IF THOSE HEADERS ARE
ALREADY KNOWN. To dodge this behavior, return slightly fewer than the
maximum, to get it to go away.
0ccc885371/src/main.cpp (L6274-L6280)
Without this change, communication between a partially-synced `zebrad`
and fully-synced `zcashd` looked like this:
1. `zebrad` connects to `zcashd`, which sends an initial `getheaders`
request;
2. `zebrad` correctly computes the intersection of the provided block
locator with the node's current chain and returns 160 following
headers;
3. `zcashd` does not check whether it already has those headers and
assumes that any provided headers are new and re-validates them;
4. `zcashd` assumes that because `zebrad` responded with 160 headers,
the `zebrad` node is ahead of it, and requests the next 160 headers.
5. Because block locators are sparse, the intersection between the
`zcashd` and `zebrad` chains is likely well behind the `zebrad` tip,
so this process continues for thousands of blocks.
To avoid this problem, we return slightly fewer than the protocol
maximum (158 rather than 160, to guard against off-by-one errors in
zcashd). This does not interfere with use of the returned headers by
peers that check the headers, but does prevent `zcashd` from trying to
download thousands of block headers it already has.
This problem does not occur in the `zcashd<->zcashd` case only because
`zcashd` does not respond to `getheaders` messages while it is syncing.
However, implementing this behavior in Zebra would be more complicated,
because we don't have a distinct "initial block sync" state (we do
poll-based syncing continuously) and we don't have shared global
variables to modify to set that state.
Relevant links (thanks @str4d):
- The PR that introduced this behavior: https://github.com/bitcoin/bitcoin/pull/4468/files#r17026905
- https://github.com/bitcoin/bitcoin/issues/6861
- https://github.com/bitcoin/bitcoin/issues/6755
- https://github.com/bitcoin/bitcoin/pull/8306#issuecomment-614916454
We modeled a Bitcoin `headers` message as being a list of block headers.
However, the actual data structure is slightly different: it's a list of (block
header, transaction count) pairs. This caused zcashd to reject our headers
messages.
To fix this, introduce a new `CountedHeader` struct with a `block::Header` and
transaction count `usize`, then thread it through the inbound service and the
state.
I tested this locally by running Zebra with these changes and inspecting a
trace-level log of the span of a peer connection that requested a nontrivial
headers packet from us, and verified that it did not reject our message.
If the limit is less than the ideal, try to increase it to the ideal.
If that doesn't work, try to increase the limit as high as possible.
If the limit is still less than the minimum, panic.
The `CoinbaseData` parses the block height separately from the rest of the
free-form coinbase data. However, it had two bugs:
1. It did not require that the height was canonically encoded;
2. Its canonical encoding was incorrect relative to the BIP34-inherited encoding.
This meant that we computed some transaction hashes incorrectly, because when
we re-serialized the coinbase transaction, we would canonically serialize the
coinbase transaction (using the incorrect definition of canonical, bug 2). And
we didn't notice that the wrong definition of canonical encoding was being used
because we accepted what we thought were non-canonically encoded heights.
The relevant rules are here: 877212414a/src/script/script.h (L307-L346)
This commit changes the encoding to reject non-canonically encoded heights, and
to match the correct encoding rules. We check that at least one
non-canonically encoded height is correctly rejected using a new test vector.
The database format increments because we saved a bunch of wrongly encoded blocks.
This discrepancy was originally noticed by @teor2345, who pointed out that a
previous version of the block 202 test vector (now preserved as "bad block
202") did not match the block from zcashd.
As a side effect of computing Merkle roots, we build a list of
transaction hashes. Instead of discarding these, add them to
PreparedBlock and FinalizedBlock so that they can be reused rather than
recomputed.
This commit adds Merkle root validation to:
1. the block verifier;
2. the checkpoint verifier.
In the first case, Bitcoin Merkle tree malleability has no effect,
because only a single Merkle tree in each malleablity set is valid (the
others have duplicate transactions).
In the second case, we need to check that the Merkle tree does not contain any
duplicate transactions.
Closes#1385Closes#906
* implement inbound `FindBlocks`
* Handle inbound peer FindHeaders requests
* handle request before having any chain tip
* Split `find_chain_hashes` into smaller functions
Add a `max_len` argument to support `FindHeaders` requests.
Rewrite the hash collection code to use heights, so we can handle the
`stop` hash and "no intersection" cases correctly.
* Split state height functions into "any chain" and "best chain"
* Rename the best chain block method to `best_block`
* Move fmt utilities to zebra_chain::fmt
* Summarise Debug for some Message variants
Co-authored-by: teor <teor@riseup.net>
Co-authored-by: Jane Lusby <jlusby42@gmail.com>
Some checks use the same blocks, so we take a copy of the block borrows
before using them. That way, we don't have to manage the position of the
iterator between checks.
Temporary fix so that Zebra's default logs support a typical workflow:
1. Developer or user runs Zebra with the default config
2. They send the logs to a terminal
3. When they see a bug, they copy-paste the last few log lines into a
bug report
This is the same change that was merged in #1373 and reverted in #1375.
We'll create a consistent logging design for Zebra in ticket #1381.
* Make debug_stop_at_height and ephemeral work together
* if `debug_stop_at_height` and `ephemeral` are set, delete the database
files after reaching the stop height
* drop or flush the database before `debug_stop_at_height` exits Zebra
This commit changes the state system and database format to track the
provenance of UTXOs, in addition to the outputs themselves.
Specifically, it tracks the following additional metadata:
- the height at which the UTXO was created;
- whether or not the UTXO was created from a coinbase transaction or
not.
This metadata will allow us to:
- check the coinbase maturity consensus rule;
- check the coinbase inputs => no transparent outputs rule;
- implement lookup of transactions by utxo (using the height to find the
block and then scanning the block) for a future RPC mechanism.
Closes#1342
Henry de Valence
teor
dependabot[bot]
Jane Lusby
Alfredo Garcia
Deirdre Connolly